No tax rebate for ‘Ice Kacang Puppy Love’ 初恋红豆冰
Updated 11 September 2010
Ice Kacang Puppy Love 初恋红豆冰 gets 20% tax rebate
Updated 24 August 2010
No tax rebate for ‘Ice Kacang Puppy Love’
LOCALLY-PRODUCED Chinese movie Ice Kacang Puppy Love, which was a box-office hit after raking in RM4mil, will not enjoy entertainment tax rebate as it has been classified as a foreign movie, China Press reported.
The movie, directed by Tan Kheng Seong or popularly known as Ah Niu who made his name in Taiwan with his pop songs, does not meet the criteria for a 20% rebate as less than 60% of the movie script was in Bahasa Malaysia.
The cast of the movie included other Malaysians who had made it big overseas like Lee Sinje, Victor Wang, Gary Chaw and Fish Leong.
The newspaper quoted Federation of Chinese Associations of Malaysia president Tan Sri Pheng Yin Huah as saying that the Treasury Department should waive the tax.
“This movie did not only receive impressive box office in Malaysia but also good reviews from Taiwan and other countries.
“The authorities should appreciate the movie rather than penalise it,” he said.
Ah Niu, who shot to fame in Taiwan with his hit song Look over here, girl across the street, directed and produced his maiden movie under his newly set up film production company Very Good Pictures.
The movie was based on his childhood in Penang, and Ah Niu played a secondary school student who was secretly in love with a school mate, played by Lee.
Wang, Chaw and Leong play the pair’s childhood friends.
Source : The Star
If you know and understand Mandarin, watch this video below.
If not, let me tell you what was being said in the video above.
Ah Niu 阿牛 陈庆祥 is a MALAYSIAN singer/actor and recently became a director with his movie 初恋红豆冰 Ice Kacang Puppy Love. A local movie production featuring heritage sites from Penang talking about a simple love story with a whole cast of MALAYSIAN born artists.
From the video above, the host actually ask Ah Niu 阿牛 that did he managed to settle his debts which he replied NOT YET.
Alright, for your information, Ah Niu 阿牛 have spent all his savings on making this movie happening, he placed a lot of effort in it to fulfill his dreams of directing as well as sharing the background of where he grew up - PENANG, MALAYSIA and he had to even borrow money to get this movie up in the last stage of production. Thus resulting in him in debts.

Now, this LOCALLY made movie production 初恋红豆冰 Ice Kacang Puppy Love is categorized as A NON LOCAL MOVIE/FOREIGN MOVIE by Malaysian Government as what Ah Niu 阿牛 the director have said in the video above. Why? because the language used in the film is Mandarin.
Only local production films using “Bahasa Melayu” can be categorized as MALAYSIAN made films.
Thus with that reason, the Malaysian Government can get 20% profitfrom total gross as tax.
Eh since when we have such stupid government policy? Does the policy/rule really exist?
I mean like, if yes, then a MALAYSIAN working so hard to make a LOCAL MALAYSIAN FILM and even promoted a few places in PENANG, MALAYSIA end up having the film categorized as a NON-MALAYSIA FILM/OVERSEA FILM and have to “buta-buta” give 20% to the MALAYSIAN Government, Woots!!
How is it that our local movie industry is going to grow if that’s the case?
Do we plan to have our movies making it big with such policies?
No wonder nobody is really willing to go on with local movie productions that uses English/Mandarin/Tamil in it.
*No i’m not condemning the Malays, i’m against the stupid policy that’s all.
*shakes head*
| anyShare分享到: | |
| |
Comments
No related posts.









about 1 year ago
malaysia boleh! 1 Malaysia! kononnya.
about 1 year ago
malaysia ma …. Malay is the 1st….
about 1 year ago
20% of profit? I thought 20% of total gross? Because Ah Niu says the box office gross is RM 4mil and he have to pay RM 800k for tax.
Simon Seow´s last [type] ..We Can Has Free Beer
about 1 year ago
> Tiffanie : haih very sad..
> Jack Ng : i don’t mean to say that though…
> Simon Seow : you are right, my bad.. Edited Haha
about 1 year ago
This is stupid, so called 1 malaysia huh.
nicole´s last [type] ..Its All About Lee Hom
about 1 year ago
Dropping by ere. =). Smiles..
about 1 year ago
whats wrong oh malaysia./…
zzzzz
i see why many malaysian rather to work at other country than malaysia….
joshuatly´s last [type] ..Twitter Weekly Updates for 2010-08-16
about 1 year ago
I would rather work at other country, pay tax to that gov than contributing money to this gov that has discriminatory policies against my own race!
infact, in this foreign country now, i’m treated much much much fairer and better than my own gov!!!
about 1 year ago
when i go oversea i also dare not say im from malaysia. Coz when i mention then people will say ” Oh, Altantuya, Oh Anuar” zzzz.. duno wanna feel proud or feel embarrassed.
MsXeRoZ´s last [type] ..Heart2Heart- When Nobody Knows
about 1 year ago
yeah this is what you call Satu Malaysia
about 1 year ago
i think Ah Niu’s explanation about the 20% tax is not 100% accurate. For the author of this blog, this policy exists very long time ago when every film were imposed 20 % tax.
However, in the early 80s the Malaysian Film Producers Association had lobbied the government for the tax rebate to be given as an incentive to help local film producers. Thus, Finas came out with the incentives in the form of the Compulsory Screening Scheme and 20 percent tax rebate to local Film.
At that time the definition of local film are not clearly defined.
Currently, the 20 per cent tax rebate for local films is only given to Malay language films made by local film producers but it is only applicable to local films that have more than 70 per cent of their dialogue in Malay. The association and Finas at that time had neglected other local languages as the film industry was dominated by Malay Film.
Thus, the current Malaysian Film Producers Association president, Ahmad Puad Onah , said the association had sent a memorandum asking for equal treatment of all Malaysian-made films to Finas in July last year. The memorandum was also submitted to the Information, Communication and Culture Ministry.
what we can do is just wait and see wheter Finas will amend the policy as you know Malaysia is very slow in such application.
Anyway Ah Niu made a good knocking as it’s already 1 year and Finas has yet come out with the resolution, it’s just that his remark may be seen as Sedition…
about 1 year ago
for u chinese tards who tried to drag race issue over a stupid reason of this movie, by all means pack ur junks and leave malaysia IMMEDIATELY. u guys have been said about LEAVING long since the middle-earth! no one gonna loose nothing by the absence of u ungrateful pricks.
@ joshuaongys: no offense to u or other chinese, but like u mentioned b4, u have no intention condemn malays. so do i, only imma totally against these ungrateful pricks…
about 1 year ago
> nicole : apparently it’s an old policy..
> JLean : thanks!
> joshuatly : too many stupid rules set by people from the past
> starrysky : which country are u at now hmm?
> MsXeRoZ : oh well..
> ryan : the idea of 1 malaysia is good but the reality is bad
> Andrew : thanks for the further information/insights!! Appreciate it, do you have a blog or anywhere else tat we can get further updates on this?
> porno : well…. chill first there, the way you talk is a bit too much also hahaha Chill Chill =)
about 1 year ago
This is totally bull shit. By the way, I don’t think malay is stupid. They’re the smartest race in malaysia. You know why? When we’re working on something, malay do not care. But when we finished, they sure will appear and ask for profit, tax, blah blah blah…
From merdeka, malay already got us, they took the perdana menteri for how long? What’re the promises they’d made? They even think to correct the history about this. smart ass
about 1 year ago
the things u said, it’s not entirely true… well
about 1 year ago
malaysia is getting from bad to worse…i foresee a continuous brain drain n finally, this god-forsaken country will be dominated by dumb-greedy politicians…oops, its actually happenin right now..my bad…
about 1 year ago
actually, our country is better than much countries out there if you want to compare the politicians and the issues being raise that is =D
about 1 year ago
true,,,our country is indeed better off than some countries…but points to ponder : Is our so-called “beloved” country looking for improvement ? or r they planning to rot with their laid-back nonchalant attitude ? Looks like “Wawasan 2020″ should be changed to “Wawasan 0022″…1 word : pathetic!
about 1 year ago
i am talking the government, not the ppl..we all know the minorities are a hardworking bunch..who strived to earn every single cent they have today…ppl like Ah Niu should be applauded for his success of making a Chinese-Msian movie..but with the msian gov asking for a slice of the cake just becos it wasnt in Bahasa Melayu ? Fuck them! Ah Niu is better off making a movie in Taiwan, China or HK!
about 1 year ago
the people with power in their hands couldn’t care much i guess, sad case
about 1 year ago
get your facts right, ah niu is from ipoh not penang!
about 1 year ago
Of course from Penang la since he was born in Penang.
about 1 year ago
> ipohmali & Andrew : =)
about 1 year ago
Foreign movie? What! Man thats just ridiculous
Jeff Awesome´s last [type] ..When Money Gets In The Way
about 1 year ago
They rebate already given bro….and it’s truely local movie
about 1 year ago
> Jeff Awesome : The cabinet have agreed mutually to give the movie a tax rebate =)
> Andrew : Decision was made yes but they have get the money lol. Anyhow still cheers! =)
about 1 year ago
best local movie =)
about 1 year ago
if no 1 said anything, i’m pretty sure the rebate goes into the Gov’s pocket…cos its “wang orang cina”
about 1 year ago
For those “bumiputra” who posted hatred remarks here, i’ve only got 1 rebuttal & thats FUCK-OFF! Even the Singaporean-Malays look down on you guys…mayb you guys should start to reflect & think WHY instead of hollering “cina balik cina”